Wednesday 24 January 2018

Background Checks on Employees

Authors: Donovan Cheah (Partner) and Adryenne Lim (Legal Executive) (Donovan & Ho)

Tales of errant employees are not unheard of. We are dealing with people after all; it is a fact of life to be faced with a diversity of characters and personalities, both good and bad. In ordinary interactions, individuals can just walk away and avoid dealing with difficult personalities. However, the remedy of “walking away” has no application in the employment arena: employment relationships are bound by contract, and in order to terminate the relationship, the burden is on the employer to justify that it is for just and reasonable cause, which, if challenged by the employee, may involve claims of unfair dismissal which are often costly to defend.

Thus, before an employee is hired, employers should undertake appropriate vetting procedures to ensure that the employee is both suitable for the job and do not have personality issues which may bring future complications to the employer, such as the following:

 
•  The employee may cause the work environment to be unpleasant that the overall morale of other employees are affected
          •  The employee may cause disruptions to the company’s business (e.g. due to high absenteeism, lack of suitable skills for the job)
          •  In the event that it becomes necessary to terminate the employee, the employee must bear the risk of having to defend against claims of unfair dismissal.
While there is no fool proof way to assess a potential employee’s suitability, undertaking proper vetting procedure may nonetheless help, albeit to a certain extent. The vetting exercise should include taking steps to verify that the information given by the employee is true and accurate, and should be undertaken before and not after the employee is hired. This advice may sound obvious to many, but there are cases where the employer had overlooked or did not consider it necessary and was subsequently forced to deal with the consequences.

The case in Khoo Kim Loang and Shock Media Studio Sdn Bhd (Award No: 51 of 2018) is illustrative of this point. In this case, the company decided to conduct investigation into the employee’s background after the employee started exhibiting signs of trouble such as poor attitude. The result of the investigation showed that the employee had lied in his resume by saying that he had worked for companies which were later found to have never existed, and the employee was terminated as a result.

What followed after the revelation about the employee’s lies and his subsequent termination should be taken as a tale of caution for employers. Notwithstanding the employee’s conduct in faking his resume, the company was forced to defend against the claim of unfair dismissal.

The Company eventually agreed to settle this case knowing full well that fraud was committed because most of the witnesses had already left the Company and the other representatives of the Company were too busy to attend to the trial.  Despite the settlement, the Court perused the documents and pleadings filed and formed a view that there was sufficient evidence to prove that the employee had lied in his resume which justified the termination.

Another interesting and troubling fact about the case is that it was also later found that the employee had been involved in a string of other industrial court cases whereby a fair number of other companies had agreed to settle the case (without admission to liability). The Court listed a total of fourteen unfair dismissal claims filed by the Claimant against his former employees. It may be inferred (though there may be other plausible explanations), that just like the company of this case, the other companies may have settled for other reason not relating to the merits of the employee’s claim.

In normal situations, an amicable settlement of unfair dismissal claims will usually result in a simple award from the Court confirming the settlement and the withdrawal of the employee’s claim. In this particular case, notwithstanding the settlement, the Industrial Court proceeded to consider the merits of the employee’s claim anyways and publish its findings. The Industrial Court took this unusual step due to the seriousness of the allegations against the employee:

“It will do well for employers to carry out more thorough vetting of CVs submitted by prospective employees to save themselves time and money unnecessarily spent on litigation such as in this case. The Court is of the view that based on the research of leading companies that clearly shows that CV fraud is on the rise, it is time for employers to check the CVs of prospective employees more thoroughly before making any job offers. And the Court is writing this Award in the hope that it will raise awareness amongst employers as the Court had a similar case in 2016…”

Key Take-Aways:

Employers should carry out proper vetting exercise before making any hiring decisions (with regard to the employee’s right to privacy according to international law standards). Information on unfair dismissal cases are publicly available on the Industrial Court website, and employees can incorporate this into their reference checks. This is important to reduce the chances of hiring problematic employees and being engaged in unwanted litigation should the relationship go sour.

An amicable settlement between parties may not necessarily shield the facts of the claim from being considered by the Industrial Court. As a court of “equity and good conscience”, the Industrial Court may nevertheless still go beyond the settlement of the parties and publish its findings on the conduct of the parties if the allegations are serious enough or are of public interest.

This case further demonstrates the need for reform of the unfair dismissal landscape. Companies and employers may often be put to unjustified costs and expenses in defending  frivolous unfair dismissal claims. An employee who knowingly files a frivolous unfair dismissal claim often suffers little consequence except perhaps an unfavourable award from the Industrial Court.




51 comments:

  1. Great Share,
    For more details on kindly visit background verification India

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wonderful blog with many helpful Informations. kindly visit
    Background Verification companies in Hyderabad for more

    ReplyDelete
  3. Background checks on employees, I think it is necessary for work-quality & related issues. Thanks for sharing.

    check stub maker
    paycheck stubs

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your article is great!!! Thanks for sharing such valuable practical points. Background verification companies in India

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi,



    Background verification is a federal legislative term which can not be avoided as it is a basic tool to manage data redundancy on a identical name which might be trouble to recruiting firm to understand which one is real and where the mistake happening for what reason? We are cFirstCorp, regulatory complain redress staff for decades of work experience towards simplicity, reliable and corporate friendly data resolution by checking employee backgrounds.














    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you for Sharing information on Employee background check

    ReplyDelete
  7. Background check in Singapore


    Welcome to AK Global Investigation Company, AK Global Company is specializes in the corporate investigation in Singapore which comprises a holistic range of services. We offer the employee check-ins and background check-ins service in Singapore.


    https://investigation-akg.com/

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Employee check in Singapore


    Welcome to AK Global Investigation Company, AK Global Company is specializes in the corporate investigation in Singapore which comprises a holistic range of services. We offer the employee check-ins and background check-ins service in Singapore.


    https://investigation-akg.com/

    ReplyDelete
  10. This blog is very helpful for looking at solutions about employee background checks. Plz, go over the link.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Great Post! This information give some information which we really need it.
    Private Investigator Malaysia

    ReplyDelete
  12. Divorce Cases Investigations & Settlements the harsh reality is that there is almost no opportunity for the truth to come out on its own.. This leaves you with the feeling of being trapped and confused on what to do and whom to believe. You even start to doubt your own sanity.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Corporate investigation Singapore

    Corporate Investigation - AK Global Company is specialized for corporate investigation in Singapore. Our teams provide you a wide range of corporate investigation services in Singapore. Contact us now - + (65) 6222 7227


    to get more - https://investigation-akg.com/corporate-investigation/

    ReplyDelete
  14. Good private investigator

    Welcome to AK Global Investigation Company, AK Global Company is specializes in the corporate investigation in Singapore which comprises a holistic range of services. We offer the employee check-ins and background check-ins service in Singapore. 


    to get more - https://investigation-akg.com/

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hiring a security company can help you do background check
    Event Security Dubai

    ReplyDelete
  16. Employee check in Singapore

    Welcome to AK Global Investigation Company, AK Global Company is specializes in the corporate investigation in Singapore which comprises a holistic range of services. We offer the employee check-ins and background check-ins service in Singapore.

    to get more - https://investigation-akg.com//

    ReplyDelete
  17. Background check in Singapore

    Welcome to AK Global Investigation Company, AK Global Company is specializes in the corporate investigation in Singapore which comprises a holistic range of services. We offer the employee check-ins and background check-ins service in Singapore.

    to get more - https://investigation-akg.com//

    ReplyDelete
  18. Awesome information! Such a wonderful reference! Thanks for all the hard work you have obviously put into this!
    Private Detective Malaysia
    Investigation Services Malaysia

    ReplyDelete
  19. I am a big fan of your blog. i am so excited by read of your blog's content. really great post.

    Background Screening Company in USA

    ReplyDelete
  20. Employee check in Singapore

    Welcome to AK Global Investigation Company, AK Global Company is specializes in the corporate investigation in Singapore which comprises a holistic range of services. We offer the employee check-ins and background check-ins service in Singapore.

    to get more - https://investigation-akg.com/

    ReplyDelete
  21. Wonderful blog with many helpful Informations. kindly visit
    Private Detective Malaysia

    ReplyDelete
  22. This is such an amazing site! I really enjoyed reading the content. Thanks!

    Best Criminal History Check Services New York

    ReplyDelete
  23. Thank you, Nice information shared, I appreciated your work Thank you.
    Visit here:- OT staffing company in New York

    ReplyDelete
  24. Great reading and extremely comprehensive post – pretty much covers everything...
    Employment Checks and Screening
    Pre Employment Screening

    ReplyDelete
  25. Hey what a informative post, Thanks for sharing this. Try to post this kind of useful content blog posts. so that everyone aware of the situation. I appreciated your work Thank you.
    Visit here:- Therapist recruiting company in New York

    ReplyDelete
  26. Can nicely write on similar topics! Welcome to here you'll find out how it should look. phone hacking

    ReplyDelete
  27. Thank you for this detailed information! This is some of the highest quality content I’ve ever come across....
    Employment Checks and Screening
    Pre Employment Screening

    ReplyDelete
  28. Hey what a informative post, Thanks for sharing this. Try to post this kind of useful content blog posts. so that everyone aware of the situation. I appreciated your work Thank you.
    Visit us: Pre Employment Screening Services in USA

    ReplyDelete
  29. It is very helpful more informative the article for Background Checks. Thank you so much for sharing this article.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Hey what a informative post, Thanks for sharing this. Try to post this kind of useful content blog posts. so that everyone aware of the situation. I appreciated your work Thank you.
    Visit here:- New York criminal background check

    ReplyDelete
  31. This is a fantastic post. I found this blog to be quite interesting and informative. Continue to share more insightful posts. Also check out Pre-employment Verification Malaysia.

    ReplyDelete

  32. Informative Write up about background screening ! Thanks for sharing !

    ReplyDelete
  33. Thank you for this detailed information! This is some of the highest quality content I’ve ever come across...

    ReplyDelete
  34. Thank you for your post. This is excellent information. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site

    https://www.cheatingspouse.com.my/

    ReplyDelete
  35. This post will be very useful to us. I like your blog and helpful to me. nice thoughts for your great work.

    https://www.cheatingspouse.my/

    ReplyDelete
  36. It is really a great work and the way in which you are sharing the knowledge is excellent. Thanks for your informative article

    https://www.privateinvestigation.my/

    ReplyDelete
  37. Great piece of information, Thank you for sharing the updated one..

    Post Employment Screening

    ReplyDelete

One month extension for SST returns and payment of tax

The Royal Malaysian Customs Department (RMCD) has announced a one month extension (until 31 July 2021) for the submission of SST-02 forms an...